Skip to content

Insights

How to hire a Finance Manager

Hiring a Finance Manager? Learn how to define the role, decide who owns reporting and controls, and ask practical interview questions.

Written by BC Recruit · 2 minute read · Published

Before hiring a Finance Manager, agree what you need them to take ownership of. Is the priority getting monthly accounts out on time, improving cash forecasting or helping department heads understand their figures? That answer will shape the brief and the questions you ask at interview.

Finance Manager or Financial Controller

Titles vary between businesses. One company’s Finance Manager is another’s Financial Controller. The useful distinction is the work. Reporting means the monthly accounts, the timetable and the explanation that goes with the numbers. Financial controls cover reconciliations, approval limits and checks at month-end. Commercial advice means helping department heads understand their figures and the consequences of a decision. Ask which of those three the role owns, and which stays with a finance director, the owner or the board.

Decide what the role owns

List the decisions this person will take without referring them upwards, and the decisions that stay with the finance director, the owner or the board. A manager who is asked to 'own the finance function' but cannot appoint their own assistant, challenge a sales forecast or speak to the bank will notice the gap quickly.

Then describe a normal month. When does the close start, which systems are used, who else is in the team, and which reports already exist? Candidates can judge a role from that description more reliably than from a list of software logos.

Separate technical strength from commercial partnership

Some finance managers are excellent at the integrity of the ledger and the discipline of the close. Others are at their best in conversation with operations, translating numbers into a choice. Many businesses need both, and very few single hires are equally strong at each. Choose the main priority and ask each candidate for an example of how they’ve handled it.

  • Who will this person spend most of their time with?
  • What should be true six months after they start?
  • Which part of the current process is painful, and which part must not be disturbed?
  • Is a qualification essential, or is relevant experience enough for this brief?

Interview for evidence, not chemistry alone

A useful finance interview asks a candidate to walk through a close, a cash problem or a difficult conversation with a non-financial manager. You are listening for what they personally did. A calm manner is valuable. It is not a substitute for the work.

Give the candidate the same courtesy. Let them meet the person they will work for, show them the shape of the team, and be honest if the reporting pack is still being built. People who are good at this work will ask.

Make the offer easy to understand

Salary, bonus, hours, place of work and the reporting line should be consistent with the conversations you have already had. A late change reads as carelessness, even when it is not meant that way. If you use a recruitment consultancy, ask them to play the offer back in writing before it goes out.

Hiring a permanent Finance Manager? Tell James about your team, who the role reports to and what you need the person to achieve in their first six months.

This is general guidance written by BC Recruit. It is not legal, tax or accountancy advice, and it has not been reviewed by an external adviser.

Discuss your finance vacancy

More on accountancy & finance recruitment.